Top 5 Steak Misteaks


By Shannon Hayes



Selling grassfed meat at a farmers' market is great work, if you can get it.  Folks who are inclined to buy your product are also very likely to make terrific friends.  The double bonus is that these folks have a habit of buying your meat and then inviting you to their house to eat it with themÉamazing!  I mind my P's and Q's as best I can on these off-farm excursions, but admittedly, I have a teeny control streak that takes over whenever I learn that steaks are on the menu.  I offer to cook them for my guests. 


Is that rude?  I don't mean to be rude.  It's just that, well, I have a deep fondness for our grassfed steaks, and it wreaks havoc with my inner peace (and my stomach) to see them treated with anything other than complete reverence in the kitchen.  None of my customers ever buys a steak without getting a complete lecture on how to cook them indoors and out on the grill (you can get those instructions here), but I've learned that, in spite of my careful lectures, mistakes are sometimes made.  Here are the top 5 steak mistakes I've observed, even if folks follow my recipes precisely:


1. Wet steak.  Thawed steak is going to be moist.  In order to sear it properly, it must be dry before you put it on the grill or in the frying pan.  If the steak is not blotted dry with a towel before you apply salt and pepper, it will not sear, it will steam. 

2. Wrong pan size.  If you are cooking your steaks indoors, be sure to choose a skillet that allows ample room to sear them.  When the steaks are too crowded, even if they have been blotted dry, the excess moisture will cause them to steam rather than brown, leaving them with an unpleasant gray pallor.  Make sure your steaks have at least 1 inch of space around them in the skillet to prevent this from happening.

3. Wrong direct-heat temperature.   Often in our hunger for a great steak, we fail to wait for our grills our skillets to heat up properly.  If the grill or skillet is not hot enough, the meat will start to roast, but it will not achieve that glorious sear that adds flavor.  If grilling, hold your hands about 4 inches above the grate.  When you can hold it there for no more than 4 seconds, the grill is hot enough for you to sear your meat.  When cooking indoors, place the skillet over a hot flame.  When you see steam rising off the skillet, you are ready to grease it with a little fat and begin frying it.

4. Failure to allow indirect cooking time.  High heat is critical only when we begin cooking steaks to achieve the sear.  A steak should be exposed to high direct heat for no more than 2 minutes per side.  After that, in order to guarantee tender and juicy meat, it should be removed from the flames and allowed to finish in indirect or low heat.  If you are cooking the steak on the grill, simply move it off the flames and put it on the side of the grill that is not lit, set the cover in place, and allow it to cook for about 5-7 minutes per pound.  If you are cooking it indoors, once the steak has seared, transfer the skillet to a 350 degree oven for about 5-7 minutes per pound (or to a 200 degree oven for about 10 minutes per pound).  During that indirect time, the internal muscle fibers will come up to temperature slowly without contracting too tightly and toughening.  Also, the proteins and sugars will have time to caramelize over the surface of the meat, giving the steak that characteristic glossy look and rich taste.

5. Wrong doneness temperature.  USDA temperature guidelines suggest that beef should be cooked to a minimum temperature of 145 degrees.  Yuck.  When you are using reliably-sourced grassfed meat, you donÕt run the same risks of consuming food borne pathogens.  Thus, cook the steak to an internal temperature of 120 degrees for medium-rare,, 140 degrees for well-done. 

6. Marinating the wrong meat.  Did I say there were only 5 commonly-made mistakes?  Oops.  I just thought of another one.  So there are actually six.  At my market booth, folks have a tendency to purchase the rib eyes, top loins, porterhouse, t-bones and sirloin steaks when they are planning a steak dinner.  Those are terrific if you are planning to season them only with a little salt and pepper.  However, if you are planning to marinate your meat, these are the wrong steaks to bring home.  These tender cuts of meat have the most delicate flavors, and their beefiness is easily upstaged by most marinades.  Furthermore, if marinated too long, the acid in marinades pre-cooks the meat, turning it gray and leaving an otherwise tender steak mushy.  If you have a marinade you plan to use, select the lower-priced cuts, such as the sirloin tip or London broil.  Those cuts have enough extra flavor and connective tissue to stand up to the marinade.  Their more pronounced beefy flavor won't be over-powered by the stronger seasonings, and the acid in the marinade will help break down some of the connective tissue.  In my opinion, a marinade should only be applied for a few hours prior to cooking.  Excess exposure to the acids in the liquids (such as wine, vinegar or lemon juice) will turn your meat gray, and too much time in the liquid will cause the juices to leak out of the meat.


Okay, I've said my piece.  If you want to invite me over to dinner now, I promise I won't start bossing you around your kitchen-honestly.  But I might bring over a little pop quiz to check first, just to be sure-Would that be too controlling??


Shannon Hayes works with her family on Sap Bush Hollow Farm raising grassfed meat in Upstate New York.  She is the author of The Grassfed Gourmet, The Farmer and the Grill, and Radical Homemakers.  Her newest book, Long Way on a Little:  An Earth Lovers' Companion for Enjoying Meat, Pinching Pennies and Living Deliciously, is due out in September 2012.  To be notified of the book's release, or to receive her Grassfed Cooking articles, sign up for the Grassfed Cooking Newsletter, a free service for grassfed farmers and meat lovers.  Copies of her books can be purchased through at both retail and wholesale prices.



Interested in receiving The Grassfed Cooking Newsletter?  Click here.